Tuesday, January 18, 2011

The Trail of the Wild Rose by Anthony Eglin

Title: The Trail of the Wild Rose
Author: Anthony Eglin
ISBN: 9780312365479
Publisher: Minotaur Books, 2009
Hardcover, 304 pages
Genre: Amateur Sleuth, #4 English Garden mystery
Rating: C+
Source: Paperback Swap

First Line: They walked more slowly now.

A party of plant hunters who journeyed to the remote corners of China and are now dying off one by one supply Dr. Lawrence Kingston with his fourth mystery.

A colleague at Kew Gardens enlists Kingston to go to an Oxford hospital where a member of a recent horticultural expedition to China lies very seriously injured. The patient's unconscious ramblings raise questions about what happened on that expedition, about the group's objectives, and about the man's own identity. After the patient's death, Kingston interviews other members of the party, gradually uncovering a nasty conspiracy.

I have greatly enjoyed the other books in this series, but this one had a few elements that got right up my nose. Kingston's fastidiousness and vanity were emphasized a bit more in this book, and with his penchant for haring off to interview and investigate-- with and without the prior knowledge of the police-- led me to believe that the man thought of himself as a silver-haired John Steed. He also lost several Brownie points by obsessing over whether or not to be seen with a female character because she didn't wear makeup.

Kingston's friends always want to fix him up with a female so he'll be happy. With his attitude, I hope for the females' sakes that they never succeed. Speaking of friends, several times throughout the book, Kingston went to lunch with a friend to new restaurants. The result of this made the book feel more like a gourmet's tour of southern England than a mystery.

The Trail of the Wild Rose began with such promise in a biologically diverse and remote corner of the world, but it devolved rapidly into a bumbling investigation in which a former professor told the reader much more than what was shown. I sincerely hope that in the fifth book in this series, Kingston's opinion of himself is not nearly so high.

You can read this book out of order without becoming confused; however, I would suggest that, if you've never read a book in this series before, you try one of the first three. They are very enjoyable.


  1. This review has a phrase in it I would steal from you if I could ethically do it: ". . . this one had a few elements that got right up my nose."

    What a wonderful expression. You made me laugh.

  2. I liked the start of the review mainly because I liked the cover so much and then was disappointed at the end as you were not happy with the end!!

  3. Joe-- I'm glad I made you laugh. Please go ahead and use the phrase to your heart's content. It's British slang, so I have no hold over it. :)

    Mystica-- I know, but the previous three books in the series are good, and they have wonderful covers as well.


Thank you for taking the time to make a comment. I really appreciate it!