First Line: Don't look directly into the snowfall. You might accidentally see into eternity, and there are some things you don't want to know.
Grief can make you return to work too soon, and that's what happens to Helgi Reykdal. He's finding it hard to come to terms with the death of his girlfriend, Anita-- especially since the person who killed her claims it was an accident and has gone scot-free. Anita's killer? Helgi's ex-girlfriend, a violent alcoholic who subjected Helgi to escalating abuse that he's kept secret out of shame.
Helgi's boss knows he's returned to work too soon and tells him to take it easy, suggesting that he look through old cases to see if he can find anything that was overlooked. Helgi decides to go through the files on the disappearance of his predecessor, Hulda, mainly because no one seems to care what happened to her.
But when his ex-girlfriend is found dead in her bath, Helgi must put this cold case aside because he's now the prime suspect.
~
Ragnar Jónasson's third mystery to feature Helgi Reykdal, The Body in the Bath, is a tightly plotted, fast-paced puzzle that demands to be solved. What annoys me is that the identity of his ex-girlfriend's killer should not have come as a surprise. It was an annoyance, yes, but a pleasant one for this seasoned mystery reader.
Helgi has always found solace in reading from his extensive library of crime fiction, but he is suffering so much from his girlfriend's death that he can't focus on any book he tries to read. I have to stop right now and admit that Helgi is a very difficult character for me to like. My British husband would describe him as a "whiny sod," and it fits him. He'll do anything to avoid confrontation. Time after time, he comes up with the correct solution or course of action, and he puts it off, inevitably causing himself more hardship. He's the kind of character you want to grab by the lapels and shake some sense into.
I am a character-driven reader, so why do I continue to read about this "whiny sod"? Because Jónasson knows how to write stories that make me want to solve the puzzle. Having loved his Hidden Iceland trilogy featuring Hulda Hermannsdóttir, I want Helgi to find out what happened to her. It's important to me that someone else cares about her.
Another thing that I really liked about The Body in the Bath was how the investigation into Helgi's ex-girlfriend's death was conducted. Two of Helgi's fellow officers are in charge. One, Alexander, is determined to find Helgi guilty; the other, Mani, believes he's innocent. Alexander will go to any lengths to find something that looks like proof, including Helgi's choice of reading material.
Even though I really don't like him, I'm looking forward to Helgi's next appearance. Find Hulda, Helgi! Find her!
Translated from the Icelandic by Philip Roughton
eISBN: 9781250408334
Minotaur Books © 2026
eBook, 247 pages
Police Procedural, #3 Helgi Reykdal
Rating: B+
Source: NetGalley











