Thursday, July 29, 2010

Liars Anonymous by Louise Ure

Title: Liars Anonymous
Author: Louise Ure
ISBN: 9780312375867
Publisher: Minotaur Books, 2009
Hardcover, 288 pages
Genre: Suspense
Rating: C
Source: Paperback Swap

First Line: I got away with murder once, but it doesn't look like that's going to happen again.

Roadside assistance operator Jessie Dancing receives a call from a driver in Tucson who sounds as if he's being murdered. Not content to let the police handle the situation, Jessie takes a copy of the tape to the driver's wife who tells her that her husband is very much alive. Taking some time off from her job in Phoenix, Jessie finds that being home in Tucson is bringing her past back to haunt her-- a past that includes being acquitted for murder. During the course of her own investigation, a young woman Jessie meets near the site of the driver's phone call is blown up in her car, and Jessie is once more dealing with a world in which guilt and innocence are both slightly out of focus.

Ure is no stranger to the Sonoran Desert, as you can see from passages like this:

The steering wheel on Bonita's car was so hot that I wished I had oven mitts. It wasn't supposed to be this hot in September. We should have been on Simmer by now, not Deep Fry. I guided the VW to the freeway with a delicate two-finger grip that would at least cut down on the number of blisters.

Two fingers, Jessie? I've learned to drive with one fingertip! (That way only one fingerprint is burned beyond recognition.)

I enjoy Ure's writing for the setting and for the convoluted plots centered around one very conflicted main character. The more I read about Jessie, the more I realized just how damaged she was. For most people, the setting, the pacing, the plot and the main character are going to be strengths leading to enjoyable reads.

In my case, I've come to the conclusion that I'm going to have to agree to disagree. I can see all these good things as I read, but in Ure's last two books, The Fault Tree and here in Liars Anonymous, she's created two conflicted characters that drive me crazy. The main character in The Fault Tree was raised to accept blame for everything that happened. It didn't take long for me to stop feeling compassionate and to start wanting to tell her to put on her big girl panties and deal with it. I had roughly the same reaction to Jessie in this book. Jessie's childhood somehow seemed to teach her that no one was going to listen to her, and if she saw wrong being done, she was going to have to take care of it herself. However, it's never a good idea to take the law into your own hands, no matter how much Jessie disagrees with me.

While I found Jessie to be exasperating and infuriating, that doesn't mean you will. Louise Ure is an excellent writer who is skilled at intricate plots and interesting characters. Don't be afraid to give her a try just because the resident curmudgeon at Casa Kittling is sometimes easily irritated!


  1. That's a wonderfully written review.

  2. Oh....the first sentence had such terrific promise! I am sorry that characterization detracted from the enjoyment of the story.

  3. I get impatient with characters who do stupid things or just can't get over it and move on, so you aren't the only one.

  4. I think I'll pass on this one; I get irritated at wimpy characters who, like you said, need to put on their big girl panties!

  5. Man-- Thank you!

    Molly-- It can also be seen as a good thing. If the character weren't written well, I wouldn't have such a strong reaction to it!

    Barbara-- I'm glad I'm not alone!

    Lynne-- The Fault Tree was the big girl panties. Jessie is definitely not a wimp in Liars Anonymous. She's already gotten away with murder!

  6. Hm. I will reserve my judgment.

  7. I always appreciate knowing the specifics of why someone didn't enjoy a book (which is not always easy to write, at least for me) and you did that in your review. Great post!

  8. With so many great books out there, I'm always hesitant to use my reading time for less-than-good books.

  9. Dorte-- I thought you might!

    Myckyee-- Thanks! I prefer that, too, because the reasons that may make a book a "stinker" for one person may be the reasons why I'll love it.

    Beth-- It would only be less-than-good if the same things irritate you. :)


Thank you for taking the time to make a comment. I really appreciate it!