Wednesday, January 04, 2017

Open and Shut by David Rosenfelt

First Line: The Lincoln Tunnel is a scary place.

After a long, hard day of being a defense attorney in Passaic, New Jersey, Andy Carpenter wants little more than the companionship of his best friend, Tara the golden retriever. The women in his life are just too complicated. At a time when he finally thinks that he knows the answers, his dad-- a legendary ex-D.A.-- drops dead right in front of Andy during a game in Yankee Stadium. 

In shock, Andy learns that the hits just keep on coming. His father has left him a $22 million fortune Andy never knew existed as well as a racially charged murder case that could burn down City Hall. Doing his best to serve justice and to honor his father, Andy finds himself digging up political skeletons and family secrets-- both of which people are more than willing to kill him to keep.

There is definitely something in the water of New Jersey because authors with an abundance of wit seem to spring from its soil in gratifying numbers. Brad Parks, Chris Grabenstein, Jeffrey Cohen, Janet Evanovich, and David Rosenfelt... to name a few. 

Rosenfelt's Andy Carpenter is a first-rate smart mouth with quick wits and a soft heart (just like I like all my heroes). His ex-wife is a spoiled little rich girl who's never found a need to abandon Daddy, and the woman investigator in his law practice wants more commitment from him than Andy's ready to give. No wonder Tara represents his best relationship.

There are two main plot lines in Open and Shut: where Andy's father got that $22 million, and the retrial of Willie Miller, a man who was convicted of a murder he didn't commit. Both are interesting, and how Rosenfelt connects the two is very good. However, the pace is like a yo-yo. Fast. Slow. Fast. Slow. It needed some tightening to keep the book's momentum running smoothly. But this is the first of a long-running series, and since I have a penchant for canines and New Jersey writers, I know I'm going to be back for more.

Open and Shut by David Rosenfelt
ISBN: 9780446612531 
Grand Central Publishing © 2002
Mass Market Paperback, 305 pages

Legal Thriller, #1 Andy Carpenter mystery
Rating: B-
Source: Purchased at The Poisoned Pen.



  1. I'm glad you thought there were lots of things to like about this one, Cathy. In my opinion, this series does have some good points. The Andy Carpenter character grows and evolves over time. If you read more of these books, I hope you'll enjoy them.

    1. First books have got to be tough, and I could never express how much I admire authors. The good bones are here in Open and Shut, which is why I'll be reading more in the series.

  2. I really enjoy this series when I need a fun break from serious, sometimes harsh mysteries. One can always count on Andy Carpenter, his friends and dogs, to provide a nice few days of fun.


Thank you for taking the time to make a comment. I really appreciate it!