Tuesday, November 10, 2015

The Nature of the Beast by Louise Penny

First Line: Running, running, stumbling, running.

There is nothing in the world large enough to contain nine-year-old Laurent Lepage's imagination. Almost everyday the residents of Three Pines are treated to one of his tall tales. After his countless impassioned descriptions of walking trees and dinosaurs he's spotted outside the village, no one believes a word he says-- including the newest residents Armand and Reine-Marie Gamache.

...until the day that Laurent disappears and the entire village learns that one of his tall tales was actually the truth. In uncovering evil deep in the forest outside Three Pines, an old poet named Ruth Zardo knows that a monster has returned to her beloved village. The time has come to face up to weakness... and to overcome it.

I never thought this day would come. This is the first time I've been disappointed in a book written by Louise Penny, and making this admission hurts. I'm so used to writing glowing reviews of her work-- her fascinating, in-depth character studies, the sheer poetry of her descriptions-- that I'd rather not say a word at all, but...

The Nature of the Beast just doesn't measure up to her previous books. Once again we have murders in Three Pines, a tiny village that's become the Cabot Cove of Quebec. Gone are her mouth-watering descriptions of meals eaten at the bistro. Gone are her insightful characterizations. Always before even the worst of her characters have been shown to have shreds of humanity. Here characters like John Fleming are simply evil.  

In previous books, Penny would've broken our hearts with little Laurent's fate. Here he's little more than a plot device. I also experienced great anticipation knowing that my favorite character, Ruth Zardo, would have a larger role in this book, but her part fell flat. In fact, the entire book felt flat and slow.

In The Nature of the Beast, too many things stretched belief beyond breaking point-- even something based in truth like the "Whore of Babylon." I am familiar with Penny's current circumstances. Her beloved husband has Alzheimer's, and they've had to move from their idyllic life in the country to a condo in Montreal. Loved ones come before books. They always should. I've seen the deep affection her fans feel for Louise Penny. I am one of those fans, and I don't think I'm the only one who would rather she take some time off instead of risk causing irreparable harm to characters and to a village so many of us adore.

The Nature of the Beast by Louise Penny
ISBN: 9781250022080
Minotaur Books © 2015
Hardcover, 384 pages

Police Procedural, #11 Armand Gamache mystery
Rating: C+
Source: Purchased at The Poisoned Pen



  1. I'm sorry to hear that this one disappointed you, Cathy. If it's any comfort at all, you're not the only person at all who feels that way about this book. That said, though, I do hurt for Penny and truly wish her well as she deals with her situation.

    1. So do I, Margot. It would be like being in the middle of a nightmare.


Thank you for taking the time to make a comment. I really appreciate it!