Tuesday, February 23, 2016

The Case of the Dotty Dowager by Cathy Ace

First Line: Henry Devereaux Twyst, eighteenth Duke of Chellingworth, was terribly worried about his mother.

The dowager duchess has to be losing her marbles. At least that's what her son, Henry Twyst the eighteenth Duke of Chellingworth, believes. His mother insists that she saw a corpse lying on the dining room floor, but the only evidence she has is a bloody bobble hat.

Twyst retains the women of the W.I.S.E. Enquiries Agency to explain the whole thing away, but once these ladies are on the Chellingworth Estate in Wales, they find they're involved in a case that's much more complex and dangerous than anyone could have imagined.

Why the W.I.S.E. Enquiries Agency? Carol is Welsh (and since she's pregnant she's put in charge of the command center in London); Christine is Irish (and with her wealthy background, she's perfect for dealing with aristocrats); Mavis is Scottish (and a former nurse); and Annie is English (and not only English but a  Cockney). Put their nationalities together, and you've got the name of their agency. Not a bad idea, eh?

Cathy Ace has gathered together four women who have the personalities, skills, and blind good luck to carry off an enjoyable series. For this first book she's also come up with a brilliant mystery involving Waterloo teeth. I knew nothing about these teeth, and I certainly do enjoy learning things while I read. 

But while the cast and the mystery are first-rate, the method of delivery fell short for me. I couldn't really immerse myself in the story because most of it was told to me instead of shown. Instead of following along with the characters, becoming accustomed to their voices, and learning things as they learn them, we're told about almost all of it, and that puts a distance between reader and story.

If "told not shown" doesn't bother you, The Case of the Dotty Dowager should be your cup of tea. The book certainly has a lot going for it. As for me, I'm undecided on continuing with the series.   

The Case of the Dotty Dowager by Cathy Ace
ISBN: 9780727884954 
Severn House Publishers © 2015
Hardcover, 224 pages

Cozy Mystery, #1 W.I.S.E. Enquiries Agency mystery
Rating: C+
Source: Purchased from The Poisoned Pen. 



  1. Oh, I'm sorry to hear this one didn't sweep you away, Cathy. I think it's because I'm biased (I like Cathy Ace's other series - her Cait Morgan series - very much). Still, I'm glad you found a few things to like.

    1. I was thinking of giving her other series a try, Margot. Thanks for reminding me!

  2. I've got this one on my Kindle, but have not read it yet. Interesting about the method of storytelling. We shall see how I fare whenever I get to it. This is going to be at LCC, I'm pretty sure. :-)

    1. And I'm pretty sure you're right! :-)


Thank you for taking the time to make a comment. I really appreciate it!